Featured image for Confronting a Gossiping Boss
Crucial Accountability QA

Confronting a Gossiping Boss

Dear Crucial Skills,

My boss and I have weekly one-on-ones to stay up to date on ongoing projects and initiatives. However, more often than not, my boss uses this time to gossip about her subordinates, coworkers, and superiors. On occasion, I ask, “What does this have to do with me?” but it never ends well, so I am forced to listen.

I’ve also repeatedly asked my boss to stop gossiping about me to my coworkers, but without fail, after my boss finishes a one-on-one with someone else, they run up to my desk with a tidbit about me.

I want to address this once and for all, but I also want to keep my job so I know I must be delicate. I’d like to have a better relationship with my boss, but can’t help but keep the boundaries high and thick given the circumstances.

Seeking a Trusting Relationship

Dear Seeking,

Before I get to some advice, I’m going to share a few words about issues that affect job satisfaction. My comments here are not based on a scientific study, but on more than thirty years of consulting with organizations and teams. I hope that at the end of this, you’ll see why I started here.

It’s important to make a distinction between a “friend” and an “accomplice.” A friend is someone who helps you; an accomplice is someone who helps you get in trouble. It is often hard to tell the difference. In the moment, when someone encourages you to do something or engages you in a conversation, it is difficult to foresee the consequences. So, what seems to be a friendly gesture can become the act of an accomplice. Over the years, in hundreds of organizations, I’ve seen numerous ways in which colleagues become accomplices. Two categories are clearly at the top of the list.

First, colleagues go to silence. There is an epidemic of silence in organizations all around the world, and the consequences are severe. Problems aren’t addressed, standards are lowered, wasteful practices are continued, and so on.

When people don’t speak up about crucial issues, they become accomplices. Being silent can be a private, individual act because each person has to weigh his or her options and decide if speaking up is the best option. More often than not, the person chooses caution over candor and so problems persist or fester. Peer pressure is also involved in a person’s decision to remain silent. Colleagues become accomplices when they make suggestions like, “We don’t bring things like that up.” Or, “You do that and it will limit your career.” Or, “Upper management doesn’t listen, ever!” Beware of similar comments.

The second way colleagues become accomplices is by gossiping. Gossip can be identified when you or someone you see talks about a person but not to the person. Almost everyone identifies gossip when they see it or hear it, and yet sometimes this gossip is labeled as something more positive like, “I was just venting.” Or, “I was just talking with a friend.” Gossip clearly comes with many negative consequences. Trust and respect are diminished—this is true of the team and it is ultimately true of the gossiper. In addition, the time people spend gossiping is non-value-added time. Work isn’t getting done. And with weaker relationships, future work will be harder to do.

My point is that you are right to concern yourself with these issues. Silence can be deadly. Gossip is hurtful. So what do you do when you face these immediate, costly issues?

I’ll start with a common indirect strategy people use particularly when they don’t feel personally capable to hold a direct conversation or they don’t think they have a strong enough relationship to hold a direct conversation. This strategy is known as the “ground rule” strategy. Ground rules are specific commitments a team agrees to work on that will help them function more effectively. This is done in a small group by brainstorming and it ends with a couple of commitments.

Ground rules help clarify needed behaviors and define boundaries. For example, I’ve seen the following ground rules:

  1. If we have an issue with a team member, we will talk to that person directly, privately, and in a professional way.
  2. In our conversations about our colleagues, we will be positive and supportive.
  3. If someone talks to us about a colleague in a way that is not positive, we will encourage him or her to enact rule #1.

These ground rules are not a panacea. They need to be modified when necessary. You should address these rules in team meetings by asking two questions—”How are we doing?” and “What could we do better?” Ground rules create clear expectations that can positively influence behavior and can make holding others accountable more likely. One of the benefits of this strategy is that it engages the boss and the whole team. You don’t have to hold a dozen conversations over time. You might want to see if your boss will lead this conversation. If you can, you are more likely to deal with the issue “once and for all.”

Finally, I would like to offer some advice for a more direct conversation. I talked about silence and gossip at the beginning of my response because, when you talk to your boss or your colleagues, you will need to explain what you are trying to achieve. What are the benefits, and what are the costs you are trying to avoid? I hope my descriptions will help.

As you’ve noted that you’ve had several conversations with your boss, I think you need to make sure you address the real topic. It could be gossip is not the main issue; it could be that when you have a talk and your boss agrees to take some actions, she doesn’t. The real topic is that you see a pattern of breaking commitments and that is affecting your working relationship. If you share your intentions—what you are trying to do and what you are not trying to do—and then share the facts that you see, you will have the right issues on the table.

I talked about ground rules because I think you have a group problem and you need a solution that will include the group. You may want to practice with a partner or friend before you address the issue again. But you need to address it.

I wish you well,
Al

Headshot

Al Switzler

Al Switzler is a New York Times bestselling author, keynote speaker, and leading social scientist for organizational change. For thirty years, Al has delivered engaging keynotes for an impressive list of clientele including AT&T, Xerox, IBM, and Sprint. Al’s work has been translated into twenty-eight languages, is available in thirty-six countries, and has generated results for three hundred of the Fortune 500. read more

8 thoughts on “Confronting a Gossiping Boss”

  1. I’m disappointed in your answer because essentially, you told him that he needed to have this conversation with the boss, but you didn’t tell him how. I see a problem in his own actions, in that he did not say to the boss that he was uncomfortable about hearing gossip about others, rather he asked the boss not to gossip to others about him. I must admit I too had a boss like this, but did not speak up, just fumed in silence. Eventually her unprofessionalism, which carried over into other areas, was recognized and she was demoted. However, had I to do it over again, I would have stopped her when she started speaking about others, with a comment about not being comfortable having that conversation behind their back, and then redirecting the conversation elsewhere. However, I agree with you that it needs to be a group discussion as it’s clear that others in this person’s group are not discouraging the behavior effectively either. But does the person go behind the boss’s back to organize his coworkers for an intervention, or how exactly does he get the group to take action together?

  2. I feel that I need to make a comment regarding your reply to Seeking. I agree that in a perfect world your advice would work well, but we don’t live in a perfect world and I think that confronting this gossiping boss is at best a ticket to the cold shoulder and at worst a ticket to ride. I have worked at many places where this happens and I think that it’s so prevelent in our society that it’s really a tough thing to squelch.
    My only advice is to say that she is very busy as ther is so much work to do that she really doesn’t have time to chit chat or something might be missed. I would advise her to try and rise above it by just replying to the boss in a positive manner and refusing to join in on the people bashing. It says to me that this boss is not to be trusted with anything personal at all. Maybe in time she will tire of the gossip and just get on with her job, but until then act like a crustacian and clam up.

    1. I agree so much with what you have to say.
      My situation is that I work for the school district in my county.
      I took this job because I am a single mother and I want to be off when my son is off.
      I have requested a school transfer from the big boss at the district and did give her a few details about the situation to only be treated cold when I went back to work the next day.
      Word got around in less than 24 hours.
      When I think about it now; it’s just funny.
      I’ve always said that I’d rather work with all men.
      Thank you again for your insight .

  3. This whole series of response on the issue of gossip is so good. Thank you to all of you. Your service is much needed at the work place and in the world. sa

  4. i’ve said before that i don’t like that you guys have quotes from your own authors in what used to be the more inspiring quote section, BUT this one is totally worthy. thankyou for this small piece of interpersonal technology.
    terry, i’m so sorry you feel like clamming up is a solution: haven’t these guys made it patent that there’s a better in-between? of course the boss sucks and it’s hard to work with her, but that attitude can’t help i don’t think… the reasonable rational person thing works most of the time, but having no hope is so demoralizing.

    1. Have a supervisor like that. Since from day 1, he gossips about his other colleagues and students and seem very delightful in putting people down. Currently he has been gossiping about me and I feel unjustified for the things he said. Confronting him is useless as we have tried and he thinks that we are all not good enough for him but he never spend quality time educating but spend it gossiping about us or to us..

Comments are closed.